Editor’s Note: We’ve all been there – a closet full of clothes and no idea what to wear, or the need for a stylish new outfit and no idea where to start. Stitch Fix is one of the most popular services out there for clothing rentals, but I always love to compare services to find the best deal that works for me. Fortunately, there are several different alternatives to Stitch Fix, which we discuss below. You can look through these options to pick the best clothing subscription services for your lifestyle, saving you time on shopping and stress about new outfits.
Whether you are looking to update your closet or just don’t have the time to shop, Stitch Fix has become the go-to for clothing subscription boxes. Its personal styling service combines the talents of its stylists with data science to recommend the perfect outfit just for you.
It may seem like the foolproof solution for all of your wardrobe needs with its free returns and flexible price ranges, but, much like anything else, Stitch Fix isn’t necessarily the best in the department. That’s why we’ve rounded up the best Stitch Fix alternatives that can offer a better fit for you.
For Meticulous Shoppers: Nuuly
Quick Facts
Subscription: Yes
Fee: $88 rental fee
No. of Items: 6
Returns: Free
Sizes: XXS to XXL
Unlike Stitch Fix, Nuuly is a clothing rental service that lets you rent six items a month for $88. You get to pick them from a collection of high-end items. It’s part of the URBN group, so if you regularly shop at Anthropologie and Urban Outfitters, you’ll be happy to know that you can now rent these brands’ items instead of buying them. Laundry and damage fees are already included in the price so you won’t have to worry about incurring additional fees with a stuck-zipper mishap or a red wine disaster.
At the end of the month, you return the items for free as long as it’s within your normal shipment. And if you find yourself having a hard time letting go of a cute top or a shimmery dress that fits you like a glove, Nuuly gives you the option to purchase the item, usually at a discounted price. You can cancel anytime, but if you want to retain your preferences and referral rewards, you should pause your subscription instead.
What we really like about Nuuly though is that since subscribers leave reviews for every item they’ve rented, it’ll be easier for you to pick out what items to include in your shipment.
For High-End Personalized Styling: Trunk Club
Quick Facts
Subscription: No
Fee: $25 styling fee
No. of Items: 6-10
Returns: Free
Sizes: XXS-4X
The luxury department store Nordstrom offers its own personal styling service in the form of Trunk Club. Just like Stitch Fix, a stylist will pick out items for you but the difference is that you can preview and make changes to your trunk before it is shipped. Trunk Club charges a $25 styling fee per trunk, which can be credited toward your purchase. If you have a Nordstrom debit or credit card, the styling fee is waived.
Trunk Club’s pricier styling fee (Stitch Fix’s is $20) is justified as you get to receive more items (up to 10!) and get access to thousands of upscale Nordstrom brands. What’s more, you get an in-depth consultation with your stylist via phone, chat, or email. They don’t simply rely on the prerequisite style quiz.
The 5-day returns are quite convenient with options for free pickups or drop-offs at FedEx and Nordstrom stores. Since Trunk Club is not a subscription service, you can order a trunk anytime you want and there’s no need to worry about pausing or canceling your account.
For Athleisure Lovers: Fabletics
Quick Facts
Subscription: Yes
Fee: $49.95 membership fee
No. of Items: 1-2
Returns: Free
Sizes: XXS-4X
Fabletics is one of the best Stitch Fix alternatives for sporty girls. This much-loved brand founded by actress Kate Hudson offers an extensive and inclusive line of stylish activewear. Its VIP membership program costs $49.95 per month ($24 for new members) and it includes a Member Credit that can be used to get an outfit or any item worth up to $80. This means you can get a bra top and a pair of Fabletics’ signature leggings every month that you are a member.
With new style arrivals coming every week and various fits and coverages, you’ll surely be using up your Member Credit every month. On the off chance that you don’t find anything you like, you have the option to skip a month or hold on to your Member Credit for up to a year.
Other awesome membership advantages include 20% to 50% discounts on all activewear, free access to the Fabletics fitness app, and free shipping for all orders over $49. Membership cancellation can be done anytime.
For Plus Size Shoppers: Dia & Co
Quick Facts
Subscription: Yes
Fee: $20 styling fee
No. of Items: 5
Returns: Free
Sizes: 0X-5X
Shopping for plus-size clothes is hard enough as it is, so just imagine the frustration of getting a subscription box with a surprise of ill-fitting clothes. Dia & Co comes in as the best Stitch Fix alternative for plus-size women, carrying lifestyle brands like Beyond Yoga and classic labels like Ralph Lauren. Not only does it cater exclusively to women with sizes ranging from 10 to 32, but it also takes into account different body types.
Dia & Co currently offers two types of subscription boxes: Style Box and Activewear. Either box contains five items, has a 5-day return policy, and costs $20 for the styling fee that can be credited toward your purchase. You can choose between an on-demand or automatic Dia plan for your boxes. Plus, you can stop your subscription whenever you need.
What we love most about Dia & Co is that it offers a whopping 25% discount if you decide to purchase all of the contents in the box.
For the Budget Conscious: Nadine West
Quick Facts
Subscription: Yes
Fee: $9.78 shipping fee
No. of Items: 4-6
Returns: Free
Sizes: S-3X
If you are looking for simple and trendy pieces minus the hefty price tag, you can turn to Nadine West as the best and cheapest Stitch Fix alternative. Unlike other subscription boxes, you don’t have to pay a styling fee. Instead, you only need to pay a $9.78 shipping fee, which can then be credited toward any outfit that you end up buying.
A box from Nadine West contains four to six items, each of which costs only $10 to $30. You can expect a typical mix of shirts, cardigans, dresses, skirts, and shorts in your box, based on your style profile. The item quality is about on part with well-made fast fashion brands, and items lean casual or business casual at most.
Occasionally, Nadine West throws in surprise pieces and seasonal items, like a necklace or a scarf. You have three days to decide which items to keep and send back.
Typically, you’ll receive a clothing subscription box every 30 days but you can change the shipping frequency to whatever you like. You can also skip, pause, or cancel your Nadine West subscription easily.
For Designer Items: Rent the Runway
Quick Facts
Subscription: Yes
Fee: starts at $89 rental fee
No. of Items: 4
Returns: Free
Sizes: XS-2XL
From 7 For All Mankind jeans to Zac Posen handbags, Rent The Runway offers designer rentals from over 700 brands at a starting price of $89 per month ($69 trial fee). You get to rent four designer items at a time and you can keep them for as long as you like. However, you can’t get new items if you don’t return your previous rentals.
Rent The Runway has three membership levels, the highest of which allows you to get a total of 16 designer items per month. Higher tiered memberships grant full closet access where you can get your hands on premium styles that have a retail value of up to $3,500.
This monthly subscription already includes dry cleaning and minor repair coverage, so you can party without a worry in a fabulous Missoni or Herve Leger dress. Moreover, it offers a free fit do-over where you can exchange an item you can’t wear for something else. Canceling or pausing your Rent The Runway subscription can be done free of charge.
For Amazon Prime Members: Prime Wardrobe
Quick Facts
Subscription: No
Fee: Free with Amazon Prime
No. of Items: 3-8
Returns: Free
Sizes: XXS-5X
Prime Wardrobe is an exclusive program for Amazon Prime members (including free trial members!) where you can conveniently “try before you buy” three to eight items from the comfort of your home. Not all items listed on Amazon are included under Prime Wardrobe but you are sure to find clothes, shoes, and accessories from many popular brands including Champion, Tommy Hilfiger, Lacoste, and Adidas.
Once you receive your Prime Wardrobe box, you have seven days to try on and decide which items to keep. You can then ship back any item you don’t like for free. Since Prime Wardrobe is a benefit for Amazon Prime members, this program can be accessed any time and it will only end when you cancel your Amazon Prime subscription.
If you need a little help with choosing the right styles, Amazon also offers Personal Shopper by Prime Wardrobe, which will set you back $4.99 per box. Unlike other clothing subscriptions, this styling fee can’t be credited to any of your purchases.
Fashion Subscriptions for All!
With so many Stitch Fix alternatives, there’s a fashion subscription out there to suit every style and need, from casual to fancy to athletic. From Rent the Runway and Trunk Club’s selection of high-end garments to the low-priced offerings at Nadine West, there’s a subscription out there that will work with your budget, as well. So are you ready to spruce up your wardrobe?